DID YOU KNOW?
You can call your insurance carrier
directly to
submit a claim.

Click here to find your carrier's claims
phone number.

Contact Us

The experienced professionals at Forrest Sherer Insurance can help you with insurance solutions that offer the best coverage and the greatest value for your insurance dollar.

General Contacts

Commercial Insurance-
John Lukens -
jlukens@fsiinsurance.com

Bob Prox -
bprox@fsiinsurance.com

David Marietta -
dmarietta@fsiinsurance.com

Neil Marchese -
nmarchese@fsiinsurance.com

John Wright -
jwright@fsiinsurance.com

John Hayes -
jhayes@fsiinsurance.com

Corey Potter -

cpotter@fsiinsurance.com
Chad Cates -
ccates@fsiinsurance.com
Loren Stigall -
lstigall@fsiinsurance.com
Jennifer Moreland
jmoreland@fsiinsurance.com

Surety / Construction-
Bart Douglas -
bdouglas@fsiinsurance.com

Linda McHolland-Readinger

lmcholland-readinger@fsiinsurance.com


Commercial CSRs-

Kevin Beel

kbeel@fsiinsurance.com

Margaret Downs
mdowns@fsiinsurance.com
Julie Eslick
jeslick@fsiinsurance.com
Sharon Farris
sfarris@fsiinsurance.com

Joyce Howard
jhoward@fsiinsurance.com
Laura Hutson
lhutson@fsiinsurance.com

Roberta Smith
bsmith@fsiinsurance.com
Jackie Wallace
jwallace@fsiinsurance.com

Jennifer Wallace

jnwallace@fsiinsurance.com




Claims-
Donna Bartlett
dbartlett@fsiinsurance.com
Sandy Schlenz
sschlenz@fsiinsurance.com


 

Personal Insurance-
Chris Reynolds -
creynolds@fsiinsurance.com

Katha Market -
kmarket@fsiinsurance.com
Dana Shotts -
dshotts@fsiinsurance.com
Amy Fitzgerald -
afitzgerald@fsiinsurance.com

Casey Sampson-
csampson@fsiinsurance.com

Jeff Reynolds -

jreynolds@fsiinsurance.com


Life & Health Benefits/Financial Products-
Leah Fouts -
lfouts@fsiinsurance.com

Jacque Pentell -
jpentell@fsiinsurance.com

Jason Lester -
jlester@fsiinsurance.com
Patty Byrd

pbyrd@fsiinsurance.com
Janice Davidson

jdavidson@fsiinsurance.com


Long Term Care-
Mark Lammers-
mlammers@fsiinsurance.com
Lorene Sporer

lsporer@fsiinsurance.com


Loss Prevention Services-
Jon Stinson -
jstinson@fsiinsurance.com
Scott Hendrix -
shendrix@fsiinsurance.com


Commercial Placement -
Kathleen Lemont
klemont@fsiinsurance.com
Neva Pitts
npitts@fsiinsurance.com
Dawn Stanfield
dstanfield@fsiinsurance.com
Jodi Tate

jtate@fsiinsurance.com


Corporate Office - 24 N. 6th St.
Contracts / Licensing -

Jackie Cossio

jcossio@fsiinsurance.com

Human Resources -

Anita Alabaugh

aalabaugh@fsiinsurance.com

 

Business Insurance Center Personal Insurance Center Claims Center

24 N. 6th Street
PO Box 900
Terre Haute, Indiana 47808
Telephone 812-232-0441
Fax 812-232-0926

Hours: 8:20 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
[map]

1219 Ohio Street • P.O. Box 506
Terre Haute, Indiana 47808
Telephone 812-232-6011
Fax 812-232-0926
Hours: 8:20 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.


[map]

Telephone 812-232-0441
Fax 812-232-0926