Contact Forrest Sherer

The experienced professionals at Forrest Sherer Insurance can help you with insurance solutions that offer the best coverage and the greatest value for your insurance dollar.

Business Insurance Center

Personal Insurance Center

Claims Center

Evansville Insurance Center

24 N. 6th Street
PO Box 900
Terre Haute, Indiana 47808
Telephone 812-232-0441
Fax 812-232-0926
Hours: 8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
[view map]
[get directions]
1219 Ohio Street
P.O. Box 900
Terre Haute, Indiana 47808 Telephone 812-232-0441
Fax 812-232-0926
Hours: 8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
[map]
[get directions]
24 N. 6th Street
PO Box 900
Terre Haute, Indiana 47808
Telephone 812-232-0441
Fax 812-232-0926
Hours: 8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
[view map]
[get directions]
123 NW 4th Street
Evansville, Indiana 47708
Telephone 812-232-0441
Fax 812-232-0926
Hours: 8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
[map and directions]



Commercial Insurance-

John Lukens
jlukens@fsiinsurance.com

Bob Prox
bprox@fsiinsurance.com

David Marietta
dmarietta@fsiinsurance.com

Neil Marchese
nmarchese@fsiinsurance.com

John Wright
jwright@fsiinsurance.com

John Hayes
jhayes@fsiinsurance.com

Chad Cates
ccates@fsiinsurance.com
Loren Stigall
lstigall@fsiinsurance.com
Tim Congleton
tcongleton@fsiinsurance.com
Robin Stover
rstover@fsiinsurance.com
Dan O'Leary
doleary@fsiinsurance.com

Glen Stover
gstover@fsiinsurance.com

Jim Brown
jbrown@fsiinsurance.com

 

Surety / Construction-

Bart Douglas
bdouglas@fsiinsurance.com
Debbie Hutts
dhutts@fsiinsurance.com

 

Loss Prevention Services-

Jon Stinson
jstinson@fsiinsurance.com
Scott Hendrix
shendrix@fsiinsurance.com

 

Commercial Support Team-

Anita Alabaugh
aalabaugh@fsiinsurance.com
Margaret Downs
mdowns@fsiinsurance.com
Julie Eslick
jeslick@fsiinsurance.com
Sharon Farris
sfarris@fsiinsurance.com
Joyce Howard
jhoward@fsiinsurance.com
Laura Hutson
lhutson@fsiinsurance.com

Nikki Price
nprice@fsiinsurance.com
Dawn Stanfield
dstanfield@fsiinsurance.com

Jackie Wallace
jwallace@fsiinsurance.com

 

Claims-

Donna Bartlett
dbartlett@fsiinsurance.com
Sandy Schlenz
sschlenz@fsiinsurance.com

 

 




Personal Insurance-

Chris Reynolds
creynolds@fsiinsurance.com

Katha Market
kmarket@fsiinsurance.com
Dana Shotts
dshotts@fsiinsurance.com
Amy Fitzgerald
afitzgerald@fsiinsurance.com

Casey Sampson
csampson@fsiinsurance.com

Jim Brown
jbrown@fsiinsurance.com

Bert Smith
bsmith@fsiinsurance.com
Brenda Cox
bcox@fsiinsurance.com

Jamie Bell
jbell@fsiinsurance.com

Robin Wilson
rwilson@fsiinsurance.com

Life & Health Benefits/Financial Products-

Jacque Pentell
jpentell@fsiinsurance.com

Leah Fouts
lfouts@fsiinsurance.com

Jason Lester
jlester@fsiinsurance.com

Brandon Adamson
badamson@fsiinsurance.com

Kevin Beel
kbeel@fsiinsurance.com

Erin Rowings
erowings@fsiinsurance.com
Erin Harbaugh
eharbaugh@fsiinsurance.com
Patty Byrd
pbyrd@fsiinsurance.com


 

Long Term Care/Financial Products -

Mark Lammers
mlammers@fsiinsurance.com
Lorene Sporer
lsporer@fsiinsurance.com

 

Commercial Placement -

Kathleen Lemont
klemont@fsiinsurance.com

Jennifer Moreland
jmoreland@fsiinsurance.com
Neva Pitts
npitts@fsiinsurance.com

Jodi Tate - Call Center
jtate@fsiinsurance.com

 

 

Corporate Office - 24 N. 6th St.

Contracts / Licensing -

Jackie Cossio
jcossio@fsiinsurance.com

 

Human Resources -

Anita Alabaugh
aalabaugh@fsiinsurance.com

 

IT -

Kathy Sprouls
ksprouls@fsiinsurance.com

Joshua Stevens
jstevens@fsiinsurance.com

 

Accounting -

Carol Koehler
ckoehler@fsiinsurance.com

Katie Dilling
kdilling@fsiinsurance.com

Lindsay Hopkins
lhopkins@fsiinsurance.com


DID YOU KNOW?

Requesting a change on your insurance policy is as easy as 1,2,3.

Click here to get a
policy change form.





   
careers    privacy/legal